Penske Media Sues Google Over AI Overviews.

In a landmark case for the publishing industry, Penske Media Corporation (PMC), the parent company of major publications like Rolling Stone, Billboard, and Variety, has filed a lawsuit against Google and its parent company, Alphabet. The lawsuit, filed in a Washington, D.C. federal court, is the first of its kind from a major U.S. publisher directly targeting Google's "AI Overviews" feature.

The Core Allegations of Penske Media.

PMC alleges that Google is abusing its dominant position in the search market to unlawfully use journalistic content to create AI-generated summaries. The lawsuit claims that this new feature, which appears at the top of search results, is causing a significant decline in traffic and revenue for its websites. According to PMC, about 20% of Google searches that would have led to their sites now feature an AI Overview, and their affiliate revenue has dropped by more than a third since late 2024.

The lawsuit argues that Google has "coerced" publishers into a no-win situation: either allow Google to use their content for AI Overviews and suffer a loss in traffic, or opt out of the feature and risk being completely removed from Google's search results, which would be "devastating" for their business. This, they claim, upends the "fundamental bargain" between Google and publishers, where content is indexed in exchange for web traffic.

Google's Response to Suits.

In its defense, a Google spokesperson has called the lawsuit's claims "meritless." Google maintains that AI Overviews provide a better user experience and actually help send traffic to a greater diversity of websites. The company argues that AI Overviews encourage people to use search more, which in turn creates new opportunities for content to be discovered. Google has stated it will "defend against these meritless claims."

Broader Industry Context.

This lawsuit is part of a growing trend of publishers and content creators challenging tech companies over the use of their material to train and power AI models. Other similar cases include:

• Chegg: The online education company previously sued Google over similar claims that AI Overviews were harming its business.
• The New York Times: The publication has a pending lawsuit against OpenAI for using its copyrighted content to train its models.
• Anthropic: The AI company recently agreed to a $1.5 billion settlement with a group of authors in a copyright lawsuit.

The lawsuit from Penske Media represents a major test case that could have significant implications for the future of digital publishing and the use of AI in search. It raises fundamental questions about copyright, compensation, and the relationship between content creators and the platforms that distribute their work.

Also Read: 

• Google Files Lawsuit Over BadBox 2.0 Android Botnet Infecting Over 10 Million Devices.
• European Union Fines Google €2.95 Billion for Adtech Abuses.